I was curious what you guys thought about this since /r/squaredcircle is in full blown internet panic mode. I personally didn't like the Rumble match from roughly Bryan's elimination onwards, but I'm nowhere near as extreme in my distaste as those guys are. Maybe it's because the PPV only cost $9.99 and I got 4 weeks of NXT to go with it, instead of the old days when I'd hate the card and have to give my cable company an extra $40 that month.
I'm glad you guys are mentioning that Bryan may have come back early. He actually was a lot more mobile than I expected at the Rumble, but I'm also guessing he's not ready for, say, 25-35 minutes that you'd expect from him in a WM title match. It is good for business to build his return to prominence instead of just instantly re-anointing him as the King.
One thing I've noticed that is a huge problem with the WWE since I subscribed to the Network in November and while I've casually watched a few Raws in that time span is the utter lack of suspense these days. I think this was a problem in the past, too, but now that I've stood back and can see the forest for the trees, I feel like I'm more aware of it than when I was at my most avid fandom back in the Attitude era. In a regular match, this means too much emphasis on finishers. In a PPV match, this means that the first finisher is rarely the end. For the Royal Rumble match, this meant the stakes were too high for "just anyone" to win and the filler is way too easy to differentiate from the actual contenders. As it got towards #30 coming to the ring, was anyone actually concerned that Big E or Swagger might win this thing? Of course not. Maybe one thing WWE could learn after last year with Bryan and what looks like a difficult Road to Wrestlemania with Reigns is that some extra flexibility might be worth it, and removing that clause to winning the match may have merit.
Overall, I think it's a shame that we're talking so much about Reigns the day after the Rumble, and not enough about Bray Wyatt. I think it's funny how fickle the IWC can be, as they loved the Shield but now hate Reigns even though Ambrose, and to a lesser extent Rollins, had a much smaller role in that group. Reigns has grown less as a character since then, but he had a significant head start, and his injury certainly curtailed things for a bit.